"First Contact" opens with a stunning sequence—a shuttle approaching Earth in the 32nd century. The Golden Gate Bridge, rebuilt after the Burn, gleams in the morning sun. San Francisco looks familiar yet transformed. This is our first extended look at post-Burn Earth, and it's gorgeous.
Our protagonist, Sidra, narrates her arrival. She's the first of her species to attend the Academy, carrying the weight of her entire world's hopes. Sound familiar? It should—Trek has always excelled at stories about outsiders finding their place.
Meet the Cadets
The premiere efficiently introduces our ensemble:
Sidra (first of her species at the Academy): Driven, talented, but carrying secrets about her homeworld's troubled past with the Federation.
T'Laan (Vulcan): Not your typical emotionless Vulcan. She's struggling with her emotions after a family trauma, challenging Trek conventions.
Marcus (human from Earth): Legacy admission—his grandmother was a famous captain. He's fighting to prove he's more than his family name.
Zeph (Trill, joined): The oldest of the group, their symbiont provides wisdom but also memories of past Academy experiences that don't quite match the current reality.
Bok (Tellarite): Provides comic relief but the episode hints at hidden depths—he's clearly running from something.
The dynamics established in this first hour feel natural. These aren't just archetypes; they're people.
The Mystery Begins
The episode's final act establishes the season-long mystery. During a routine tour of the Academy archives, Sidra discovers a classified file with her brother's name on it. He supposedly died in a shuttle accident three years ago—but the file suggests otherwise.
Before she can investigate further, alarms sound. The archive goes into lockdown. When security arrives, the file is gone, and Sidra is warned by a mysterious upperclassman: "Some questions are better left unasked at the Academy."
It's a classic hook, and it works. We're immediately invested in uncovering what happened to Sidra's brother and what the Academy is hiding.
Easter Eggs & Callbacks
The premiere is packed with references for Trek fans:
- The Academy building includes memorials to Kirk, Picard, Sisko, Janeway, and Archer
- A mention of "Sato Hall" (named after Enterprise's Hoshi Sato)
- The Academy's motto is displayed prominently: "Ex astris, scientia" (From the stars, knowledge)
- A holographic Boothby tends the gardens—a wonderful callback to TNG
These references enhance rather than distract, showing the writers understand what makes Trek special.
Episode Verdict
"First Contact" does everything a pilot should do. It establishes characters we want to follow, creates a mystery worth solving, and captures the optimistic spirit that defines Star Trek. The 32nd-century setting feels fresh, and the Academy provides a natural structure for serialized storytelling.
Most importantly, it feels like Trek. The emphasis on diversity, cooperation, and hope for the future is exactly what the franchise should be about. If the rest of the season maintains this quality, Starfleet Academy will be remembered as one of Trek's best spin-offs.
Rating: 4.5/5 stars
Ready to Play?
Experience all the Star Trek: Starfleet Academy challenges yourself.
Play All Star Trek: Starfleet Academy Games →