MAJOR SPOILERS for Stranger Things Season 5, Episodes 5-7. This article reveals the resolution of Jonathan and Nancy's relationship. Stop here if you haven't watched Volume 2.
Trapped Together
Volume 1 revealed Jonathan had been carrying an engagement ring—hidden inside a John Coltrane cassette tape—for days. Fans speculated whether he'd actually propose in Volume 2.
He did. Sort of.
In Episode 5 ("Shock Jock"), after Nancy fires at the atomic matter, she and Jonathan are trapped in a room where the goo is literally melting the walls. The space is filling up. Escape seems impossible.
Facing what they believe is certain death, they finally have the conversation they've been avoiding for three seasons.
The Honest Conversation
With nothing left to lose, Jonathan and Nancy stop pretending.
Nancy's Confession: She admits she's been uncertain about their future for a long time. She doesn't know what she wants from life—career, location, family—and Jonathan deserves someone who's sure.
Jonathan's Confession: He admits he's felt her pulling away. He convinced himself the ring would fix things, would force them to commit, would make the doubts go away. But he knew that was magical thinking.
About Steve: Nancy acknowledges Steve is a good guy who makes her laugh. But she's not leaving Jonathan for Steve—they're too different. Steve knows exactly what he wants (six kids, for the record). She doesn't.
About Their Love: Neither denies loving the other. They were each other's first real relationship, forged in supernatural trauma. That bond is real. But real isn't always right.
The "Un-Proposal"
Jonathan pulls out the ring—still in its cassette tape case.
But instead of proposing, he asks:
"Nancy Wheeler, will you NOT marry me?"
It's not a joke. It's an acknowledgment that they were both trying to force something that wasn't working. The ring was his way of avoiding the truth. Asking her to NOT marry him is his way of finally facing it.
Through tears, Nancy accepts.
They say "I love you" to each other—genuine, not performative—and agree this is the right ending. A mutual, loving breakup that honors what they had without forcing it to continue.
The Duffer Brothers confirmed in interviews: "That's a breakup. They are broken up."
So Does Nancy End Up with Steve?
Shippers hoping for a "Stancy" revival will be disappointed.
During her conversation with Jonathan, Nancy explicitly addresses Steve:
"He knows exactly what he wants. Six kids. A house. I don't know what I want. And I'm not going to figure it out by dating someone else."
The love triangle—which has persisted since Season 1—ends not with a winner but with Nancy choosing herself. She's not leaving Jonathan FOR Steve. She's leaving Jonathan to figure out who she is outside of any relationship.
- Team Jancy: Devastated but appreciating the mature handling
- Team Stancy: Frustrated that their ship didn't sail
- Team Nancy: Celebrating her independence
The show's message is clear: Nancy Wheeler has always been defined by her determination and ambition. Ending the series with her choosing herself over either boy is fitting.
The Real-Life Irony
Here's the twist that makes this breakup even more interesting:
Natalia Dyer (Nancy) and Charlie Heaton (Jonathan) are a real-life couple.
They've been dating since 2017 after meeting on set. While their characters are breaking up on screen, the actors remain together off screen.
Both actors have discussed the strange experience of performing an emotional breakup with their actual partner:
Charlie Heaton: "It was weird, obviously. But we're professionals. And honestly, it made the scene more emotional because we could access real feelings about relationships."
Natalia Dyer: "I think fans sometimes forget we're acting. Jonathan and Nancy's story is separate from ours. We could give the characters the ending they needed."
The irony isn't lost on the fanbase—seeing your favorite on-screen couple break up while knowing they're going home together afterward.
What This Means for the Finale
With Jonathan and Nancy officially broken up, the finale has new dynamics to explore:
Jonathan's Arc: Freed from relationship drama, Jonathan can focus on his family—particularly Will, who just came out. Their brotherhood has always been Stranger Things' most underrated relationship.
Nancy's Arc: Nancy enters the final battle as her own person, not as someone's girlfriend. Her investigative instincts and combat skills will be crucial.
Steve's Arc: Steve doesn't "get" Nancy, but he's already proven he doesn't need her to be a hero. His arc has evolved beyond the love triangle into mentorship (with Dustin) and self-discovery.
The Message: Stranger Things is ending with a statement: these characters' worth isn't determined by their romantic relationships. They're heroes because of their courage, loyalty, and love for each other—not because they paired off correctly.
Ready to Play?
Experience all the Stranger Things challenges yourself.
Play All Stranger Things Games →