ShowGamesShowGames
Spoiler Warning: This answer contains major plot details from The Sinner
The Sinner

What happened to Phoebe in The Sinner?

Quick Answer

Phoebe died during a party at a drug den. Cora was drugged and assaulted, and her memories of that night were suppressed for years.

Advertisement

Detailed Explanation

Phoebe's death is the key to understanding everything. Cora's sister was chronically ill but desperate to experience life. Cora took her to a party run by drug dealers, where things went horribly wrong. Phoebe overdosed and died. Cora was drugged and assaulted. The trauma was so severe that Cora's mind created a false narrative—she believed Phoebe died of her illness at home. The truth only emerges through Ambrose's investigation, revealing that Cora's seemingly random violence had deep roots in buried trauma.

More The Sinner Questions

Why did Cora kill the man on the beach in The Sinner Season 1?Is The Sinner connected? Do the seasons relate to each other?
Back to The Sinner Killers