ShowGamesShowGames
Spoiler Warning: This answer contains major plot details from The Sinner
The Sinner

Why did Cora kill the man on the beach in The Sinner Season 1?

Quick Answer

Cora killed Frankie because a song triggered repressed memories of her sister's death. Frankie was unknowingly connected to the trauma that destroyed her life.

Advertisement

Detailed Explanation

Cora Tannetti's murder of Frankie Belmont—a stranger on a beach—seems random until Detective Ambrose uncovers her suppressed trauma. Years earlier, Cora witnessed her sister Phoebe's death during a drug-fueled party. She was drugged and assaulted, and her mind blocked the memories. When Frankie played "Huggin and Kissin" on the beach—the song that was playing during her trauma—everything came flooding back. In that moment, Cora saw not Frankie but the men who hurt her sister. The murder was both inexplicable and tragically inevitable.

Learn More About This Killer

The Sinner

Cora Tannetti

The Beach Stabber

She didn't know why she killed. Neither did we.

I just... I had to. I don't know why.

1+ victimsCaptured

More The Sinner Questions

What happened to Phoebe in The Sinner?Is The Sinner connected? Do the seasons relate to each other?
Back to The Sinner Killers